In mitochondria, copper is a Janus-faced trace element. While it is the essential cofactor of the mitochondrial cytochrome c oxidase, a surplus of copper can be highly detrimental to these organelles. On the one hand, mitochondria are strictly dependent on adequate copper supply for proper respiratory function, and the molecular mechanisms for metalation of the cytochrome c oxidase have been largely characterized. On the other hand, copper overload impairs mitochondria and uncertainties exist concerning the molecular mechanisms for mitochondrial metal uptake, storage and release. The latter issue is of fundamental importance in Wilson disease, a genetic disease characterized by dysfunctional copper excretion from the liver. Prime consequences of the progressive copper accumulation in hepatocytes are increasing mitochondrial biophysical and biochemical deficits. Focusing on this two-sided aspect of mitochondrial copper, we review mitochondrial copper homeostasis but also the impact of excessive mitochondrial copper in Wilson disease.